Looking for newsletter sign-up examples you can copy because your own form gets plenty of views and very few sign-ups? The forms that convert best make one specific promise, ask for an email address only, and show that people like the visitor already joined.
Where the form sits matters too. Omnisend's 2026 sign-up form data puts the average embedded form at 1.28%, popups at 3.77%, and landing pages at 6.47%, so the same copy can convert five times better in the right spot.
These ten sign-up forms come from publishers and brands you can visit yourself. For each one, I note what it does and the part I'd copy.
You'll also get the sign-up patterns I'd use most, weak vs strong rewrites, and where to place each form. By the end, you'll know which one change to make first, so more of your visitors join.
Let's look at each form.
tl;dr
- The best forms make one specific promise, say how often you send, and ask for an email address only.
- Make the button say what the reader gets, like "Send me Tuesday's teardown", not "Submit".
- Put true proof next to the button: a subscriber count, logos, or one short quote.
- Placement matters. Omnisend's 2026 averages run from 1.28% for embedded forms to 6.47% for landing pages.
- Save discounts and countdown timers for special cases, and ask for extra details in the welcome email.
In this article
- What makes a newsletter sign-up form convert?
- 10 newsletter sign-up examples (and what to copy)
- The sign-up patterns to use most
- Weak vs strong sign-up form rewrites
- How many fields should a sign-up form have?
- Landing page vs embedded form vs popup
- Popups that don't annoy people
- Consent rules every sign-up form should follow
- What to test first on your sign-up form
- What happens after someone signs up
- Should you build your sign-up forms yourself or get help?
- FAQ
- Final Thoughts
What makes a newsletter sign-up form convert?
A newsletter sign-up form converts when the visitor can see the trade in a few seconds: what they'll get, how often, and why it's worth an inbox slot. The best forms add as little friction as possible and put proof right next to the button.
The parts of a high-converting newsletter sign-up form include the following:
- A Specific Promise: The headline names the outcome, the topic, and ideally the time it takes to read.
- Cadence: The form says how often you'll send, so the first issue isn't a surprise.
- One Field: An email address, and a first name only if you'll actually use it.
- A Value Button: The button says what they get ("Send me Friday's issue"), not what they do ("Submit").
- Proof: A subscriber count, a few recognizable logos, or one short quote.
- A Trust Line: One sentence on privacy and how easy it is to leave.
10 newsletter sign-up examples (and what to copy)
The ten newsletter sign-up examples below cover publishers, creators, and stores. Copy the thinking, then write it in your own voice.
1. Morning Brew: The benefit and the time cost
Morning Brew's form promises readers they'll become smarter in just 5 minutes, according to Omnisend's roundup. It's a single email field, and the form says the newsletter comes every day.
What to copy: Put the benefit and the reading time in one line. A daily newsletter asks for a lot of inbox space, so the payoff has to be obvious before anyone types.
2. The GIST: Cadence and proof in one sentence
The GIST's form packs reading time, frequency, and audience size into one line: five minutes, four times per week, to more than a million fans, as Omnisend documents. The copy is playful, which suits sports fans.
What to copy: Say exactly how often you send. Honest frequency up front is the easiest way to avoid complaints from people who didn't expect so much mail.
3. Lenny's Newsletter: Peer proof for professionals
Lenny's Newsletter leads with a clear promise of "deeply researched product, growth, and career advice," and its homepage shows over 1,200,000 subscribers. For a professional audience, a big peer count says "people like you already read this."
What to copy: Match the proof to the reader. Professionals respond to peer counts, shoppers respond to perks, and creators like to see a sample issue.
4. Marketer Milk: A logo strip next to the field
Marketer Milk promises the latest marketing news, resources, and guides, and Omnisend notes it shows 30,000+ subscribers, including people at Amazon, Google, and Microsoft. The form itself asks for an email address only.
What to copy: Put proof within a thumb's reach of the button. Even three recognizable names do more than empty space.
5. Tim Ferriss: Content you can only get by subscribing
Tim Ferriss's 5-Bullet Friday page offers a very short email every Friday with the five coolest things he found that week. He says plainly that these emails won't be on the blog or anywhere else, and adds that unsubscribing is easy.
What to copy: Give the inbox something the website doesn't have. Then lower the risk with one line about how easy it is to leave.
6. theSkimm: Pick the newsletters you want
theSkimm's sign-up page lets readers choose several newsletters at once, covering news, shopping, wellness, and finance. Each option has its own short benefit line, so readers know what each checkbox means.
What to copy: Offer real choice only when you publish genuinely different newsletters. If you send one weekly digest, extra checkboxes just add clutter.
7. The New Yorker: Daily or weekly
The New Yorker's form offers two choices, "Daily" and "Weekly," each with a short description. Omnisend points out that separate checkboxes like these give clear consent for each option.
What to copy: Let readers pick a frequency. Someone who'd never sign up for a daily email may happily take a weekly one.
8. Milk Road: Personality on the form
Milk Road's form uses playful illustrations and calls itself the number one newsletter for everyday investors, with Macro, Crypto, and AI as its topics. The form feels like the newsletter, so the first issue feels familiar.
What to copy: Make the form sound like your first issue. If your newsletter is funny, the form should be too.
9. MAC Cosmetics: A clear perk and separate SMS consent
MAC's form ties sign-up to its loyalty program with a 15% discount and a shipping perk, and it offers email and text sign-up side by side. Omnisend notes that text message consent needs its own opt-in and can't be bundled with email.
What to copy: For a store, put the perk in the headline and the button. If you collect phone numbers too, give SMS its own checkbox.
10. Woof: A quiz that segments while it converts
Woof's form asks visitors about their dog's main wellness challenge, then shows a discount based on the answer. Omnisend's data puts gamified landing pages at an average sign-up rate of 11.02%, the highest of any form type it lists.
What to copy: Use a one-question quiz when the answer changes what you'll send. You get a sign-up and a segment in the same click.
| Example | Main pattern | Best for |
|---|---|---|
| Morning Brew | Benefit + time cost | Daily newsletters |
| The GIST | Cadence + proof in one line | Fan and hobby audiences |
| Lenny's Newsletter | Peer subscriber count | Professional audiences |
| Marketer Milk | Logo strip | B2B newsletters |
| Tim Ferriss | Inbox-only content | Creators with a blog or podcast |
| theSkimm | Choose your newsletters | Publishers with several lists |
| The New Yorker | Choose your frequency | Publishers with daily and weekly sends |
| Milk Road | Personality | Niche newsletters with a strong voice |
| MAC Cosmetics | Perk + separate SMS consent | Ecommerce stores |
| Woof | One-question quiz | Stores with distinct product needs |
The sign-up patterns to use most
You don't need all ten patterns on one form. Here's the mix I'd recommend, from what belongs on most forms to what you should save for special cases:
- Use Most, a Specific Promise With Cadence: Every form needs this, and it costs nothing but a better sentence.
- Use Most, Email-Only Fields: Start here and ask for more later in the welcome sequence.
- Use Most, Proof Next to the Button: A count, logos, or a quote, whichever is true and relevant.
- Use Sometimes, Choice of Lists or Frequency: Worth it when you really publish more than one thing.
- Use Sometimes, Quizzes: Great when the answer changes what you send, and wasted when it doesn't.
- Use Sparingly, Discounts and Countdown Urgency: Discounts suit stores, but they train newsletter readers to wait for deals, and fake timers erode trust.
Pro tip: Rewrite the promise before you redesign anything. If you can't say what someone gets in about ten words, a new layout won't fix it.
Weak vs strong sign-up form rewrites
Most weak sign-up forms fail on the same few lines: the headline, the button, and the empty space where proof should be. Here are the rewrites I'd make first.
Weak headline: "Subscribe to our newsletter"
Strong headline: "One Klaviyo flow teardown every Tuesday, in 5 minutes or less"
Weak button: "Submit"
Strong button: "Send me Tuesday's teardown"
Weak proof: Nothing next to the button, or "Join our community!"
Strong proof: "Read by [your real count] store owners" (use a true number, and only once it's big enough to help)
| Weak form | Strong form | |
|---|---|---|
| Headline | Subscribe to our newsletter | One Klaviyo flow teardown every Tuesday, in 5 minutes or less |
| Button | Submit | Send me Tuesday's teardown |
| Proof | Nothing, or "Join our community!" | Read by [your real count] store owners |
Fix the headline, button, and proof line before you redesign anything.
Three line changes do most of the work.
Still stuck on the headline? Borrow a structure from these email copywriting formulas and fill it with your own promise.
How many fields should a sign-up form have?
A newsletter sign-up form should have one field, the email address, unless you'll use a first name in your very next email. Every extra field asks the visitor for more effort before they've seen a single issue.
If you do need more information, split it into steps. Omnisend's data puts multistep landing pages at 9.11% on average, because the first screen asks for the email and the rest comes after.
Pro tip: Ask for the rest in your welcome email instead. A one-click "what do you want to hear about?" question gets you segment data from people who've already joined.
Landing page vs embedded form vs popup
Use a landing page for traffic you send on purpose, embedded forms for people already reading, and one polite popup for everyone else. Each placement has a different job, and Omnisend's averages show how far apart they sit.
| Form type | Average sign-up rate (Omnisend, 2026) | Best for |
|---|---|---|
| Embedded | 1.28% | Blog posts, homepage sections, footers |
| Flyout or slide-in | 3.24% | Always-on capture without covering the page |
| Popup | 3.77% | Moments of intent, with a clear offer |
| Landing page | 6.47% | Ads, social bios, podcast and guest links |
| Multistep landing page | 9.11% | Guided sign-ups that ask for more after the email |
| Gamified landing page | 11.02% | Quizzes and engagement campaigns |
These are averages across Omnisend's customers, so treat them as direction, not a target. Most sites need all three main placements, because each one catches people the others miss.
Popups that don't annoy people
A good newsletter popup shows once per visit, appears after the reader has had a chance to see the page, and closes easily on a phone. A bad one covers the whole screen on arrival, hides the close button, and keeps coming back.
Google has a search reason to care. Its guidance on avoiding intrusive interstitials says not to cover the whole page and suggests small banners for things like newsletter sign-up prompts.
Weak popup: "WAIT! Don't go!" on page load, full screen, with a tiny gray close link.
Strong popup: A slide-in after the reader scrolls halfway, saying "Want next Tuesday's teardown? One email a week," with a clear close button.
Consent rules every sign-up form should follow
A sign-up form should only add people who actively chose to join. Gmail's sender guidelines say to avoid opt-in boxes that are checked by default and to confirm each recipient's address before subscribing them.
Yahoo's sender best practices go further on expectations. They ask senders to tell people at sign-up what mail to expect, how often it will come, and what it will look like, and to use a confirmation email.
That confirmation step is called double opt-in, and it keeps fake and mistyped sign-ups off your list. While you're testing the form on a phone, run an accessibility pass too, using these email accessibility best practices for the form and the emails that follow.
What to test first on your sign-up form
Test the headline first, because it changes the most for the least effort. The newsletter sign-up tests worth running, in roughly the order I'd run them, include the following:
- Headline Copy: Benefit and time cost vs a proof-led headline vs a perk.
- Button Text: "Subscribe" vs "Send me the tips" vs "Get Friday's issue."
- Proof Line: A subscriber count vs logos vs a reader quote.
- Placement: End of post vs mid-post vs a dedicated landing page.
- Timing: Exit intent vs a 30-second delay vs halfway down the page.
Button copy is the cheapest of these to test, and my guide to email CTA best practices gives you variants worth trying. Check each result with the A/B test calculator before you call a winner.
Small lifts add up quickly. If 10,000 people visit each month and your form moves from 2% to 3%, that's 100 extra subscribers a month, or 1,200 a year.
What happens after someone signs up
The sign-up form earns the address, and the first email earns the second open. Whichever form you copy, connect it to a welcome email sequence that sends within minutes and delivers exactly what the form promised.
The issues have to keep that promise too. My guide on how to write a newsletter covers the hook, the single ask and the edit, so the first issue reads the way the form said it would.
Once people are reading, these best practices for email newsletters keep them opening. If you're still setting up the wider system, my guide on how to build an email list covers lead magnets, platforms, and placement from zero, and a real newsletter strategy matters more than another button color test once the form works.
Need layouts for the issues themselves? These newsletter template examples show how to structure them, and my lead magnet ideas help if you want a download to offer alongside the newsletter.
Should you build your sign-up forms yourself or get help?
You can build a good sign-up form yourself in an afternoon with the patterns above, and most newsletters should. The copy is the hard part, and you know your readers better than anyone.
Help makes sense when the form converts but growth has stalled, or when the welcome sequence, referrals, and deliverability start to need real time each week. If you publish on beehiiv, my beehiiv agency team works on growth channels like recommendations and referrals, and if your store runs on Klaviyo, Managed Email gets your welcome flow and campaigns run for you every week, with me signing off the work.
FAQ
What is a good newsletter sign-up conversion rate?
Omnisend's 2026 data puts the average at 1.28% for embedded forms, 3.77% for popups, and 6.47% for landing pages. Compare your form to the average for its type, then work on beating your own last month.
How many fields should a newsletter sign-up form have?
One, the email address, unless you'll use a first name right away. Ask for anything else later, in the welcome email or a preference center.
Do popups still work for newsletter sign-ups?
Yes, when they show once, appear after some engagement, and close easily. Omnisend's average for popups is 3.77%, almost three times its embedded form average.
Should I offer a lead magnet or a plain newsletter sign-up?
Offer a lead magnet when you can solve one specific problem in about five minutes. Use a plain sign-up when the newsletter promise is already sharp enough to stand on its own.
Should I use double opt-in for my newsletter?
For most newsletters, yes. Gmail and Yahoo both recommend confirming new addresses, and it keeps fake and mistyped sign-ups off your list.
Final Thoughts
You now have ten newsletter sign-up examples, the patterns worth copying from each, weak vs strong rewrites, and benchmarks for every form type. If I had to pick one change, it would be the headline: name the outcome, the cadence, and the reading time, like Morning Brew and The GIST do.
Your next step is to rewrite your form's headline and button today, then add one true proof line beside the button. Once that's live, check that your welcome email arrives within minutes and delivers exactly what the form promised.
Russ
