An email sunset policy is a written rule for when you stop emailing subscribers who never open or click, usually after one last attempt to win them back, and then suppress them so they can't receive marketing email again.
It sounds harsh, but it protects every email you send to the people who do read them. Below, you'll get the inactive window to start with, who to suppress and who to keep, the exact sunset flow to build in Klaviyo, and why suppressing beats deleting (your future self will thank you at billing time).
Key Takeaways
- An email sunset policy defines who counts as inactive, gives them a last chance, then suppresses them.
- Klaviyo's sunset segment starts with profiles created at least 180 days ago that received at least 5 emails in the last 72 weeks and never opened or clicked.
- Judge engagement on clicks and non-Apple opens, because Apple Mail Privacy Protection can record opens nobody made.
- Suppress inactive subscribers rather than deleting them. Suppressed profiles don't count toward your Klaviyo plan.
- Google and Yahoo both recommend removing or reconfirming subscribers who don't engage.
What Is an Email Sunset Policy?
An email sunset policy is the rule that decides when an unengaged subscriber stops getting your marketing emails. Instead of mailing everyone on the list forever, you set a clear line, send a short last-chance sequence, and suppress whoever stays quiet.
Every sunset policy has the same three parts:
- A Definition of Inactive: The window and the signals that mark someone as unengaged, such as no clicks in a year.
- A Last Chance: One to three emails that give the subscriber a reason to stay or a clean way out.
- A Suppression Step: The point where anyone still silent stops receiving marketing email.
Most senders skip the whole thing. In Mailjet's Road to the Inbox 2025 report, 23.9% of respondents had a sunset policy for removing or segmenting unengaged subscribers, 58.7% didn't, and 17.4% weren't sure (which is a polite way of saying no).
Why Do You Need a Sunset Policy?
You need a sunset policy because the inbox providers judge you on how your whole list behaves, and a pile of people who never open drags that down.
Gmail and Yahoo both say so in writing. Google's email sender guidelines tell senders to consider unsubscribing recipients who don't open or read their messages, and to periodically confirm that recipients still want to be subscribed. Yahoo's sender best practices suggest sending a reconfirmation email to inactive subscribers periodically. When the two biggest free inboxes ask for the same thing, it's worth listening.
Old addresses also turn into problems over time:
- Spam Traps: Validity's guide to spam traps says an address generally has to sit inactive for at least 12 months before a mailbox provider can recycle it into a spam trap.
- Bounces: Klaviyo's bounce guide recommends a sunset flow to cut invalid address rejections by removing unengaged recipients before their mailboxes go dead. Our guide to reducing your email bounce rate covers the rest of that problem.
- Your Bill: Klaviyo's active profile guide confirms that suppressed profiles don't count toward your email plan's active profile count, so every ghost you suppress stops costing you money.
A sunset policy is one part of the bigger job of improving email deliverability, and it's one of the few parts that also saves you money.
How Long Before You Sunset a Subscriber?
About a year without any engagement is the usual line. Klaviyo's guide to re-engaging an old list says profiles that haven't engaged for over a year are generally considered unengaged, and sending to them puts your deliverability at risk.
Here are the starting points the platforms themselves suggest:
| Starting point | Inactive window | Where it comes from |
|---|---|---|
| Re-engagement campaign | No open or click in 120 days, subscribed more than 60 days ago | Klaviyo re-engagement guide |
| Sunset flow | Created 180+ days ago, 5+ emails received in 72 weeks, never opened or clicked | Klaviyo sunset flow guide |
| Generally unengaged | No engagement for over a year | Klaviyo old-list guide |
| Spam trap risk | Inactive for 12+ months | Validity |
The 120-day re-engagement window comes from Klaviyo's re-engagement campaign guide, which targets subscribers who joined more than 60 days ago and haven't opened or clicked in 120 days. Use that as the warning stage and the one-year mark as the cut-off.
Then adjust for how often people buy. A coffee subscription customer who goes quiet for six months may well have switched brands. A mattress buyer who goes quiet for a year is just doing what mattress buyers do (nobody needs a mattress email every week), so give slower purchase cycles a longer window.
Who Should You Suppress (and Who Should You Keep)?
Suppress people who keep receiving your emails and never open, click, browse or buy. Keep anyone who's showing a sign of life somewhere, even if it isn't in the inbox.
The subscribers to keep out of your sunset segment are:
- Recent Buyers and Browsers: The inactivity segment in Klaviyo's active profile guide also requires zero site activity, product views, checkouts started and orders placed, so a customer who buys without opening emails stays put.
- New Subscribers: Klaviyo's sunset flow guide only looks at profiles created at least 180 days ago, so nobody gets cut before they've had a fair go.
- Real Openers on Apple Mail: These are fine to keep, but only if the open is real. More on that below.
Apple Mail is the catch. Mail Privacy Protection can load your tracking pixel without anyone reading the email, which inflates opens and makes dead subscribers look alive. Klaviyo's Mail Privacy Protection guide explains that open events carry an Apple Privacy Open flag, and you can exclude those opens by filtering for Apple Privacy Open equals false. The flag only exists on opens from November 20, 2021 onward. Our Apple Mail Privacy Protection guide goes deeper on why open rates lie.
Pro tip: If your segment uses opens at all, add the Apple Privacy Open filter before you suppress anyone. Without it, a big chunk of your sunset segment can hide inside "engaged" (and they'll keep costing you money while they hide).
How to Set Up a Sunset Flow in Klaviyo
A sunset flow in Klaviyo is a segment-triggered flow that sends a few last-chance emails, tags whoever doesn't respond, and hands them to a suppression step.
Follow these steps to build the sunset flow from Klaviyo's sunset flow guide:
- Build the Sunset Segment: Profiles created at least 180 days ago that received at least 5 emails in the last 72 weeks and opened 0 times and clicked 0 times over all time.
- Create a Segment-Triggered Flow: Trigger it from that segment, and add flow filters so anyone who opens or clicks since starting the flow drops out.
- Write One to Three Emails: Give a real reason to stay, plus an easy way to update preferences or leave.
- Add a Grace Period: Klaviyo suggests 3 days after the last email if you send daily, and 7 to 10 days if you send less often.
- Tag the Silent Ones: Add a property update that sets Unengaged to True. This tag doesn't suppress anyone by itself.
- Suppress the Tagged Segment: Create a segment where Unengaged is true, then use Suppress current members from the segment's menu.
Step 6 trips people up. The same guide notes there's no native flow action for email suppression, so the flow only tags people. You still have to open the Unengaged segment and suppress its members, so put a recurring reminder in your calendar.
As for the emails themselves, keep them short and honest. A plain "Do you still want to hear from us?" with one button to stay and one link to leave does more than a discount ever will (a discount code doesn't fix a subscriber who forgot you exist). If you want ideas for the offer side, our win-back emails guide has a full sequence.
Pro tip: Make the last email's subject line say exactly what happens next, like "We'll stop emailing you on Friday". Clear beats clever here, because the only goal is a click from anyone who still cares.
Should You Suppress or Delete Inactive Subscribers?
Suppress them. Suppression stops marketing email but keeps the profile, its history and its purchases, so you still know who that person is if they buy again.
Suppressing and deleting an inactive subscriber compare like this:
| Suppress | Delete | |
|---|---|---|
| Receives marketing email | No | No |
| Counts toward your Klaviyo plan | No | No |
| Keeps purchase and engagement history | Yes | No |
| You can still see who they were | Yes | No |
Keeping the record matters later. Klaviyo's deliverability best practices list sending to lists that were previously suppressed for lack of engagement as a practice to avoid, and you can only avoid them if you still know who they are. Delete them and that old spreadsheet looks like a list of fresh faces (it isn't).
Klaviyo's active profile guide also points out that suppression only touches the current members of a segment. Anyone who goes quiet next month needs the next run, which is why a sunset policy has to run on a schedule. For the bigger version of that routine, see our guide to email list cleaning.
FAQ
What is a sunset policy in email marketing?
It's a rule for when you stop emailing subscribers who don't engage, usually after a final re-engagement attempt. Google's email sender guidelines recommend considering unsubscribing recipients who don't open or read your messages.
How often should you run a sunset policy?
Keep the sunset flow running all the time and suppress the tagged segment on a schedule, such as monthly. Klaviyo's sunset flow guide notes the flow tags people but doesn't suppress them, so the suppression step needs a recurring slot.
Will a sunset policy shrink my list?
Yes, and that's the point. Klaviyo's active profile guide confirms suppressed profiles don't count toward your email plan, so the list gets smaller and cheaper while the people still on it are the ones who read.
Do Apple Mail opens count as engagement?
Not reliably. Klaviyo's Mail Privacy Protection guide explains that an open with Apple Privacy Open set to true may come from Mail Privacy Protection rather than a real person, so filter those out of engagement segments.
Is a sunset flow the same as a win-back flow?
No. A win-back flow tries to bring back lapsed customers with an offer. A sunset flow, as Klaviyo's sunset flow guide describes it, is a last attempt before you tag and suppress people who stay unengaged.
Final Thoughts
You now know what an email sunset policy is, where to draw the line, who to keep, and how to build the flow in Klaviyo. The recommendation is simple: build the sunset segment with the Apple filter, switch on a short last-chance flow, and suppress the Unengaged segment every month.
Start this week by building the segment and looking at how many profiles land in it. If the number makes you wince, our free email audit will show you what it's doing to your deliverability and what to fix first.
Russ
